From the Dover Telegraph and Cinque Ports General
Advertiser, Saturday 29 January, 1848. Price 5d.
CASE OF MANSLAUGHTER ON BOARD A HAMBURG BRIG
CORONER'S INQUEST
On Monday last an inquest was held before G. T. Thompson, Esq.,
Coroner for the Borough, to investigate the circumstances attending the
death of Claus Stockfeldt, a mariner belonging to the brig Lorenz, of
Hamberg, and who died from injuries during an affray between himself and
the carpenter of the said brig.
The proceedings were commenced at the "Cumberland Inn" near the
Wellington Bridge, at two o'clock in the afternoon. The following
gentleman constituted the jury:- Messrs. Jame Duke, (foreman,) W. M.
Wood, J. Morgan, E. Sclater, John Bates, D. Dray, W. Pascall, sen., J.
Hollyer, H. Stockwell, R. C. Fuller, John Blackbourne, J. L. King, E.
Sell, and J. Johnson. The jury having been sworn, they repaired to view
the body, lying on board the Lorenz, and on their return to the inquest
room the enquiry was adjourned to the New Town Hall. On the assembly of
the jury at the Hall, the examination of witnesses was proceeded with,
and the following evidence elicited:-
Thomas Boulter, chimney sweeper: I reside in Woolcomber Street. On
Monday, the 17th of January, at about 12 o'clock, while I was standing
on the New Cross-Wall Quay, near Mr. Latham's, I saw a man, whom I have
since ascertained to be the mate of a foreign brig lying at the said
quay, hastily run and jump on board the vessel. I followed to see what
was the matter, and looking on the vessel's deck, I saw the man go into
the cook-house or cabouse, and pull out a man now present, and calling
himself Ludeweig Helwers, who had some blood on his face. Helwers
appeared to be quarrelling with another man, to me unknown, who was in
the cabouse, and I have since learnt was the cook. The mate, after
pulling Helwers out, took up a position at the door of the cabouse, and
commenced speaking to the cook. While thus engaged, the man who had
been pulled out (Helwers) came from the bulwarks, against which he had
been pushed by the mate, towards the cabouse, having as pair of
carpenter's pincers in his hand, grasped by the nippers. On reaching the
mate, he made an effort to pass him, but failing, he struck the cook in
the face with the pincers, his hand going over the mate's shoulder.
About a minute elapsed between the time of Helwersbeing pulled from the
cabouse and his striking the blow. I don't know where the carpenter got
the pincers, not did I see him stoop down to pick up anything. On the
blow being struck, the mate remonstrated with Helwers, during which the
cook came out of the cabouse, when I saw that blood was flowing from his
face. I then called Powell, the engineer of H.M.P. Onyx, for assistance,
who went on board, and I instantly ran for a surgeon. Previous to this,
however, I had seen the man who struck the cook go down the forecastle.
Henry Dickson, victualler, residing at Charlton, corroborated the
evidence given by the foregoing witness; and also stated that he saw the
pincers in Helwers' hands when he first tried to enter the cabouse.
John Cock, tidewaiter in the Dover Customs: On Monday, the 17th
instant, while on the New Cross-Wall Quay, guarding the brig Lorenz, I
saw an affray on board that vessel between two men; the prisoner was
one, and deceased the other. It was occurring in the cabouse. I called
to the mate, who was walking on the quay, and told him there had been a
row on board. He instantly jumped on deck, and parted them, dragging
Helwers out of the cabouse. Thinking the disturbance was over, I ceased
looking on; but in about a minute, or a minute and a half, hearing a
fresh noise, my aytention was again given to what was going on, when I
saw Helwers standing by the cabouse, and having a pair of pincers in his
hand. The mate was standing near, and the cook then came out of the
cabouse, bleeding from the face. Some of the crew ran to the cook's
assistance; and I, being alarmed at his bleeding so much, jumped on
board myself, and got hold of him, and supported him till other
assistance came, when I resumed my duty on the quay, and Boulter, who
was present, ran off for a surgeon.
Johann Henrienn Kruse, mate of the Lorenz: I was on the quay on the
day in question, and, as stated by the preceding witness, on going on
board the brig, found the cook, Claus Stockfeldt, and the carpenter,
Ludeweig Helwers, quarrelling together. They had hold of each other, and
I separated them, pushing Helwers away. I remained speaking to the cook
on the cause of the quarrell, and while doing so Helwers came behind me,
and, putting his hand over my shoulder, struck the cook in the face.
After the blow had been struck I saw the pincers in the carpenters hand,
but had not seen them there previously. He held the pincers by the
nippers; and the pair now produced I believe to be those with which the
cook was struck. As soon as the blow had been given the blood flowed
from his face, and I afterwards saw that there was a wound under the
cook's left eye. On finding the wound serious, I had the captain called
directly, and sent for a surgeon. I had ordered Helwers away on the blow
being struck; but my attention became directed to the man, I knew not
what became of Helwers immediately subsequent ton the affray. He had
sailed in the vessel about ten months, and always attended to his duty;
he was not a quarrelsome man, nor have I had any cause of complaint
against him. Deceased had also sailed in the vessel about the same time,
and was not inclined to be quarrelsome. He was, I believe, 21 years of
age, and died on Saturday last, on board the brig, at about half-past
two o'clock in the afternoon.
Herman Darre, the cooper on board the Loranz, identified the pincers
now produced as his property. He had used them about nine o'clock on the
morning of January 17th, and left them on deck, but could not say where.
He next saw them in the afternoon of the same day. They were then in his
tool box, but how they came there he knew not. He had seen nothing of
the disturbance; but hearing a noise, went on deck, where he saw Helwers,
who shortly after went below, to the place where witness's tools were
kept.
Johann Freidrig Kock, cabin boy of the Lorenz: On Monday, the 17th of
January, I was near the cabouse a little after eleven o'clock in the
morning, when the carpenter came for some iron that was being heated in
the fire. The cook was busy getting the dinner ready. He, however,
looked for the iron, but could not find it. The carpenter then went into
the cabouse, and began to rake the fire about with the fire-tongs in
search of the iron. The cook wished him to desist till after dinner,
but he would not, upon which he was pushed out of the cabouse by the
cook; but returning again, a scuffle ensued in the cabouse. I did not
see the pincers then, and the mate came on board and separated them.
Having done this, he (the mate) stood outside the cabouse, talking to
the cook. About two minutes passed between the mate's separating them
and the blow being struck. The blow was given over the shoulder of the
mate. I cannot say that the pincers now produced are the pair the
carpenter had, but they are the pair given to me by the cooper on my
being sent for them by the captain. I do not recollect seeing the
pincers any where on deck, nor did I see any blood on them when I took
them to the captain.
Haeinrick Jacob Mublenroth: I am captain of the brig Lorenz,
belonging to Hamburg. She came into Dover harbour on the 26th of
December last, ice-bound; and I am waiting here until the port of
Hamburg is open from ice. On the 17th of January instant, at about a
quarter to twelve, I was called from my cabin, and on going on deck
found Stockfeldt, whose body is the subject of the present enquiry,
bleeding profusely from the face. having cleansed the face, I saw a
wound under the left eye. I then had him removed to my cabin, where he
was shortly attended by a surgeon. After the wound was dressed, I sent
the cabin boy, on account of what I had heard, to bring me the pincers,
and he brought me the pair now produced. I looked at them, and saw blood
in the claw. I kept them by me until the 22nd instant, when I gave them
up to the Superintendent of Police.
By the Foreman: The iron was being heated for some repairs connected
with the pump. My orders were given by me to the carpenter through the
mate. The repairs could not have been effected without the heating of
the iron.
At this stage of the proceedings (sis o'clock) the Coroner observed
that the importance of the case rendered a post-mortem
examination of the body necessary, for which purpose he should adjourn
the inquest to the following day, at three o'clock; and the jury were
then bound over in their own recognizances (of £40 each) to attend. The
several witnesses were also ordered to be in attendance.
SECOND DAY.
At three o'clock in the afternoon, on Tuesday, the jury reassembled
at the New Town Hall, and the enquiry was resumed, as follows:
Thomas Laker, Superintendent of Police: The pincers now produced are
the pair I received from the captain on the brig Lorenz, on Saturday,
the 22nd instant.
John Coleman, jun., surgeon: On Monday, the 17th instant, about 12
o'clock at noon, I was called to attend deceased; but not being at home,
my assistant attended, being relieved by me at about four o'clock in the
afternoon of the same day. Deceased was in the cabin of the brig Lorenz;
and upon my examining him, I found there was a puncture wound below the
lid of the left eye, within the bony orbital cavity - the eye itself
being uninjured. From the appearance of the wound, it was such as would
have arisen by a stab from the handle of a pair of pincers shown me. I
should judge that the instrument passed beneath the globe of the left
eye - the resistance of its spherical shape directing the weapon
downwards. From the blood which flowed from the wound being so profuse,
as well as arterial, I should infer the ophthalmic artery, or its
branches were wounded; and of course, externally there was considerable
ecchymosis, and extravasation of blood, and the integuments surrounding
the wound. the man was in a state of great collapse, which might be
attributed, in part, to the loss of blood sustained in the morning, and
partly to the shock which the system received from so severe a stab. He
was sufficiently sensible to answer the questions I put to him through
an interpreter. There were no symptoms present which would lead me to
the supposition that the instrument itself had penetrated the substance
of the brain; but from the position and direction of the wound, I
conceived such an injury might be possible. I continued in attendance
upon him, giving such medicines as I thought necessary. For the two or
three days following Monday, deceased progressed favourably; but on
Thursday morning, the 20th, he became much worse, and complained of
great headache, attended by fever. He was still collected in his
conversation, and always spoke when a question was put to him. On
Saturday morning, the 22nd instant, the pain in the head became suddenly
intense, and other symptoms developed themselves, indicating that
compression of the brain had taken place. He became insensible, comatose
convulsions succeeded, and his death followed shortly afterwards, at
about half-past two in the afternoon of the same day. This morning (the
25th,) I made a post mortem examination of deceased. The wound I
have mentioned above, was in a direction inwards and upwards, passing
between the globe of the eye, and leaving that organ uninjured. The
course of the wound then lay through the orbital cavity, perforating the
inner wall. The portion of the bone displaced by the instrument are
large enough to form a breach in the orbital wall, about the size of
six-pence. On looking into the cranium from above, a fracture was
observed corresponding exactly with the fissure in the orbit, and
communicating with it. Several splinters of bone were detached,
protruding upon the brain. Around these small fragments there was an
effusion of fus, and other signs denoting the fact of inflammatory
action having taken place at the base of the brain, opposite the
perforation. The cause of death I believe to have been inflammation of
the brain resulting from the wound inflicted by the instrument - that
wound causing such mischief to the brain and its membranes as to produce
changes in cerebral organs that were incompatible with life. The organs
of the chest and abdomen I also examined, and found them perfectly
healthy and free from all disease. Having observed the course of the
wound, and such changes as I have described, produced by the wound, I
have no hesitation in stating that the death of deceased was distinctly
caused by the stab of some blunt-edged instrument such as the
claw-handle of a pair of pincers.
The jury having expressed that the evidence adduced was sufficient in
finding a verdict, no other witnesses were examined.
The Coroner then summed up, adverting to the principal points for the
consideration of the jury, and the legal bearings regulating the
decision to be arrived at. The witnesses, &c., then withdrew; and on
being re-admitted, the following was announced as the result of the
jury's deliberation, which lasted about three quarter's of an hour:-
The jury having taken this matter into their consideration, do find
that Ludeweig Helwers is guilty of Manslaughter, in causing the death of
Claus Stockfeldt.
The finding was then intimated to the prisoner, by means of an
interpreter, Mr. Edwards, who was also engaged as interpreter on part of
the evidence given by the mate and others of the crew. The prisoner was
also informed that he stood committed, under the Coroner's warrant, to
the County Gaol of Maidstone; and that at the Assizes to be held there
in the course of two or three months, he would have to take his trial
for the offence which he was charged to have committed. Helwers was then
removed to the custody of the governor of Dover Gaol.
The prisoner is of a somewhat short stature, stout, and dark looking;
but does not possess an appearance of asavage or cruel nature.
The burial of deceased took place on Thursday, at three o'clock in
the afternoon, at St. Martin's churchyard. The corpse was followed to
the place of interment by S. M. Latham, Esq., vice consul for Hamburgh;
the captain and crew of the Lorenz; and the captains and crews
(numbering in the whole about 50 persons) of the several foreign vessels
lying in our harbour, in which, as an emblem of respect to the memory of
the deceased, flags were flying half-mast high during the day.
|
From the Dover Telegraph and Cinque
Ports General Advertiser, Saturday 26 February, 1848. Price 5d.
CORONER'S INQUEST
FATAL ACCIDENT TO ONE OF THE POLICE
An inquest was held yesterday evening at the "Cumberland Hotel,"
before G. T. Thompson, Esq., coroner for the borough, on the body of
John Herbert, aged 24, son of Mr. Herbert, of the "Barley
Mow," who had lately joined the police force, and who was found
drowned in the pent early on Friday morning.
The jury having appointed Mr. W. Binfield, foreman, proceeded to view
the body, which was lying in the office used by Mr. Dakin, during the
progress of the harbour works; and on their return the following
evidence was given:-
Sergeant Back deposed: Deceased was a supernumerary constable in the
police force. He was on duty last night on the No. 2 Beat, from Five
Post Lane to Strond Lane, including Union Street to Wellington Bridge. I
visited him twice during the night, and last saw him at two o'clock, at
the bottom of Five Post Lane; he was then quite sober.
George Bourner, a labourer in the employ of Mr. John Hayward,
deposed: This morning, about half-past six, on going over the Wellington
Bridge to get a ladder, I saw something dark in the water over the quay
opposite Mr. Latham's house, and afterwards saw a hand, on which I
called to two men, named Friend and Harper, who came to me. They then
got into a boat, and rowed to the spot, when they took out the body.
There appeared to be about three feet water in the pent. I did not wait
to see the body brought on shore.
Ridley Friend, stoker on board H.M.P. Violet, deposed: This morning
on being called by last witness, who said there was a man overboard, I
went to the quay, and then, with George Harper, got into a boat, and on
taking the body out of the water, found from the dress that it was one
of the police. He was nearly upright, with his feet in the mud. He had a
handkerchief grasped in his hand, and his cape was over his head. We
rowed round to the Wellington stairs, and left the body in charge of
P.C. Pierson.
Mary Hogbin, wife of Mr. Hogbin, baker, Commercial quay, deposed:
This morning about a quarter before 5 o'clock while in bed, I heard loud
cries of help, and on looking out of the window, the cries appeared to
come from the water opposite Mr. Latham's quay. I opened the window, and
then heard a faint moan, which shortly ceased, and seeing no one near, I
shut the window.
By a Juror: I gave no alarm as I saw no one near. I called to my
husband, and asked if he heard the cry, and he replied "no," and that it
was only my fancy, which I thought likely, as we are often disturbed by
the noises of vessels in the harbour.
William Perkins, of H.M.P service, deposed: About a quarter to 5 this
morning I saw a policeman in his night dress standing near the "Three
Kings." I spoke to him in passing, and he seemed perfectly sober.
Edward Sweeney, labourer, deposed: This morning, 3 or 4 minutes past
5, while crossing the Wellington Bridge, I heard a splashing in the
water, as if something had fallen in; but deemed it to be the rebound
under the sluice way, I took no further notice. I heard no cries. Having
fetched my tools from near the North Pier, I re-crossed the bridge, and
while on it saw a hat floating through the bridge-way. I got a boat, and
picked up the hat, which I found to be such as policeman wear. I saw no
one on the bridge on either occasion; about seven minutes elapsed
between the times of crossing.
Verdict: Found Drowned.
|